Two Mothers Lose Bid To Stay In HK With Their Kids

"); jQuery("#212 h3").html("

Related News Programmes

"); jQuery(document).ready(function() { jwplayer.key='EKOtdBrvhiKxeOU807UIF56TaHWapYjKnFiG7ipl3gw='; var playerInstance = jwplayer("jquery_jwplayer_1"); playerInstance.setup({ file: "https://newsstatic.rthk.hk/audios/mfile_1451318_1_20190404175718.mp3", skin: { url: location.href.split('/', 4).join('/') + '/jwplayer/skin/rthk/five.css', name: 'five' }, hlshtml: true, width: "100%", height: 30, wmode: 'transparent', primary: navigator.userAgent.indexOf("Trident")>-1 ? "flash" : "html5", events: { onPlay: function(event) { dcsMultiTrack('DCS.dcsuri', 'https://news.rthk.hk/rthk/en/component/k2/1451318-20190404.mp3', 'WT.ti', ' Audio at newsfeed', 'WT.cg_n', '#rthknews', 'WT.cg_s', 'Multimedia','WT.es','https://news.rthk.hk/rthk/en/component/k2/1451318-20190404.htm', 'DCS.dcsqry', '' ); } } }); }); });

2019-04-04 HKT 14:29

Share this story

facebook

  • The Court of Final Appeal says the women, from the Philippines, can't make use of their children's rights to live in Hong Kong to stay in the SAR themselves. Photo: RTHK

    The Court of Final Appeal says the women, from the Philippines, can't make use of their children's rights to live in Hong Kong to stay in the SAR themselves. Photo: RTHK

Two former foreign domestic helpers from the Philippines have lost their final bid to be able to stay in Hong Kong with their children who are SAR residents, after a legal fight for residency that has gone on for years.

The Court of Final Appeal told the mothers on Thursday that they can't rely on the rights enjoyed by their kids to remain in the territory.

Desiree Rante Luis and Milagros Tecson Comilang came to Hong Kong to work as domestic helpers more than two decades ago. They both later got married and had children.

Luis has three boys, all under 18, while Comilang has a daughter who is 13. All four of the children are SAR residents and two of them have permanent residency.

But neither of the mothers have a legal right to be in Hong Kong, with Comilang fighting for residency since 2011 and Luis since 2014.

The Immigration Department refused to extend the women's stays, because they don't meet the criteria of any category in the city's immigration policy.

Officials also decided there are no exceptional circumstances to justify allowing the women to remain in the SAR on humanitarian or compassionate grounds.

A five-judge Court of Final Appeal panel has now unanimously backed the authorities' stance.

It rejected the women's claims that denying them permission to stay breaches Hong Kong's Bill of Rights and the SAR's Basic Law.

These rights don't apply to the pair, the panel said, because they shouldn't even be in Hong Kong.

The judges also said that it would be wrong if a person with no right to enter or remain in the SAR was able to overcome this fact by relying on someone else’s right to be here.

They also reiterated a point made earlier by Chief Justice Geoffrey Ma that there's a recognised necessity for strict and effective immigration controls in Hong Kong.

RECENT NEWS

Max-Hervé George Found The Gold In FTX's Bitcoin Miner: 1.2 Gigawatts Of Power For AI

SWI Group acquired control of Genesis Digital Assets after FTX-related disputes, aiming to convert its power-connected b... Read more

Former Trump VP Pence Is Positioning Himself As A Staunch Interventionist. Does A 2028 Run Beckon?

Mike Pence attributed the GOP's midterm losses to tariffs, corruption and, unlike other prominent GOP figures, "appeasem... Read more

Trump Implies Biden Administration To Blame For Friday's Nationwide Aviation Shutdown

A telecommunications failure linked to a router installation disrupted radar and communications with planes, prompting r... Read more

Bipartisan Efforts To Restrict Chinese Access To Advanced AI Tech In Wake Of Nvidia Scandal Are Growing: Report

Republican and Democratic lawmakers are backing legislation to tighten restrictions on China's access to advanced AI chi... Read more

Senator Fetterman Claims He Would Consider Leaving The Democratic Party If Van Hollen Becomes Majority Leader

Pennsylvania Senator John Fetterman cited disagreements over Israel as the main reason for the potential switch. Fetterm... Read more

Diesel Prices Just Dropped Below A Key Threshold. Easing Geopolitical Tensions Are Partly Responsible.

The U.S. average diesel price fell below $6 a gallon in mid-November; lower oil prices, seasonal factors and policy meas... Read more