'Compromise Offer' Over Elderly Welfare Plan

Sources have told RTHK that the government has floated a compromise proposal amid strong opposition to its plan to raise the minimum age for elderly welfare payments - but critics say it's not what is needed.

The move came later on Thursday, after lawmakers from all sides united in urging the administration to withdraw its plan to raise the age requirement from 60 to 65.

It’s understood officials are now proposing an additional allowance of about $1,000 for 60- to 64-year-olds, if they have proof from social workers that they cannot find work. The sources said the additional allowance could make up for the shortfall in comprehensive social security assistance (CSSA) payments.

The compromise was offered after legislators voted overwhelmingly to pass a non-binding motion to shelve original plan. The motion, moved by social welfare sector legislator Shiu Ka-chun, was passed by 51 votes for, two against and four abstentions. The motion also called for the government to review the entire CSSA scheme.

Lawmakers from the pro-establishment camp are said to have reacted favourably to the government compromise after meeting the Chief Executive, Carrie Lam.

But pan-democrats said it's not a workable or fair solution. They said that creating another means-tested allowance would make the welfare system even more complicated, and failed to deal with the root problem. They were also angered that Lam only invited pro-government legislators to the meeting.